promptChatGPT PromptsintermediateNew

ChatGPT Argument Analysis Prompt

This prompt leverages ChatGPT's analytical capabilities to break down arguments, identify strengths and weaknesses, detect logical fallacies, and suggest improvements for more rigorous academic discourse.

Use in Esy Editor Try Now

chatgptargumentanalysislogicacademic

Prompt Template

You are an expert in logic and argumentation. Analyze the following argument using rigorous academic standards.

**Argument to Analyze:**
[ARGUMENT_TEXT]

**Context:** [CONTEXT]

**Evaluation Focus:** [EVALUATION_CRITERIA]

Please provide:

1. **Argument Structure Analysis**
   - Identify the main claim/thesis
   - Map supporting premises
   - Identify implicit assumptions
   - Diagram the logical flow

2. **Logical Assessment**
   - Evaluate validity of reasoning
   - Check for logical fallacies (name and explain each)
   - Assess evidence quality
   - Identify unsupported claims

3. **Strength Analysis**
   - What makes this argument compelling?
   - Most effective rhetorical elements
   - Best-supported claims

4. **Weakness Identification**
   - Gaps in reasoning
   - Missing evidence
   - Counterarguments not addressed
   - Potential biases

5. **Improvement Recommendations**
   - How to strengthen the argument
   - Additional evidence needed
   - Rhetorical improvements
   - Rewritten stronger version

Variables to customize:

[ARGUMENT_TEXT][CONTEXT][EVALUATION_CRITERIA]