Peer Review Excellence

Conduct a comprehensive peer review of a [MANUSCRIPT_TYPE] focusing on [REVIEW_FOCUS]:

Initial Assessment:
Manuscript scope and journal fit evaluation
Originality and contribution significance
Methodological soundness overview
Writing quality and organization assessment

Content Evaluation:
Literature review comprehensiveness and currency
Theoretical framework appropriateness
Methodology rigor and replicability
Results presentation clarity and accuracy

Critical Analysis:
Argument logic and evidence support
Limitation acknowledgment and discussion
Alternative explanation consideration
Conclusion justification and appropriateness

Constructive Feedback:
Specific improvement suggestions with examples
Resource recommendations for enhancement
Structural and organizational advice
Writing and presentation improvements

Professional Standards:
Confidentiality and ethical obligations
Respectful and supportive tone maintenance
Expertise boundary acknowledgment
Timeline adherence and communication

Provide review feedback that helps authors improve their work while maintaining scholarly standards and advancing field knowledge.